Start by fixing the specification
Make sure both parties are pricing the same dimensions, materials, construction, decoration, packaging, acceptance requirements and production quantity. Small differences can change more than the look of the finished product.
For example, one supplier may quote screen printing on a standard cotton tote. Another may assume embroidery on a heavier fabric. The prices cannot tell you which partner is cheaper for the brief until the assumptions are aligned.
A worked example: the lowest unit price loses
Consider 1,000 identical custom fabric pouches. These figures are invented solely to show how the arithmetic works. Assume the approved product and the delivery basis are otherwise aligned.
| Cost | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|
| Unit price, 1,000 pieces | $2.80 | $2.55 |
| Goods cost | $2,800 | $2,550 |
| One-off setup/tooling | $100 | $500 |
| Packaging, per piece | $0.25 | $0.35 |
| Packaging total | $250 | $350 |
| Total before freight, duty and tax | $3,150 | $3,400 |
Offer B advertises the lower unit price but costs $250 more on these listed charges. Neither figure is a delivered or landed cost. Freight, import charges, samples and any inspection costs have not yet been included.
The point is not that Offer A is always better. The point is that a decision made from $2.55 versus $2.80 alone would be premature.
Seven checks before you call two quotes comparable
1. Are the products truly alike?
Match material grade, dimensions, decoration, colours, packaging and approved tolerances. A vague description is a risk, not a saving.
2. Is the minimum quantity for the exact version you want?
A low price at 5,000 units doesn't answer a 1,000-unit brief. Ask whether the MOQ is per model, colour, artwork or purchase order.
3. Which fixed charges are included?
Tooling, moulds, dies, colour matching, artwork preparation, pre-production setup and packaging development can change the economics.
4. What is the sample path?
One supplier may include an off-the-shelf reference, while another budgets a true pre-production sample. They are not equivalent approvals.
5. What does the delivery term actually include?
An EXW offer, an FOB offer and a DAP offer are different obligations. Check the Incoterm and named place. Clarify freight, insurance, customs clearance, duties, taxes and final delivery responsibilities.
6. When does the clock start?
“Thirty days production” may start after deposit, final artwork or sample approval. Record each dependency and compare the arrival date your customer needs.
7. Who takes responsibility if something changes?
Know the contracting seller, the agreed inspection standard, the claims process and how price or schedule changes will be approved.
The one-page comparison an agent can actually use
Put both offers into the same format. Identify confirmed facts separately from supplier assumptions and outstanding questions. Then write one sentence explaining what would change your recommendation.
For example: “Offer A currently has the lower quoted order cost, but neither offer can be recommended until packaging specifications and delivered freight terms are confirmed.”
That is a better answer than “A is cheaper.” It protects the proposal you are about to put in front of your client.
Where LuxeGreat can help
If you have an existing product, a usable specification and the quantity you expect to reorder, LuxeGreat can explore an alternative production offer. We'll focus on meaningful differences, not just a persuasive price at the top of a spreadsheet.